I have been looking for an upgrade to my camcorder lately and I used this opportunity to test how well the comparison sites from my list do the job. So I picked a search term and tried each site.
At the end of this post I have a table with results that lists what each of these websites produced including number of products and the best price.
While these results are just one snapshot of a much bigger picture, they did help me uncover certain facts that in turn resulted in a few useful shopping tips.
Many websites share the same list of products
One might think that the more sites you use for price comparison, the better result you will get. It is certainly true to some extend. However I noticed that many websites share the same product listings in results. Please read my previous post on the subject and use the facts you find there to build your own list of sites to use.
One of the tools that you might find useful is RoboShopper which is an aggregator that combines a few comparison engines under one roof. You enter your search term once and then simply switch between multiple websites to see what results each of them gives you.
Remember to re-sort the search results
Majority of price comparison websites make their living by offering merchants prominent positions in search results. These are often marked as “Sponsored” or “Certified” but they usually mean nothing more than the fact that the merchant paid to rank high in the results. Make sure you resort the list by price to avoid getting caught by this little trick.
Watch out for scam shops
Websites who have low barriers for merchants to list their products tend to list a lot of scam shops in search results. This is not the first time I face the problem. Some price comparison websites have been attempting to limit the customer exposure to these merchants. CNET for example will only show “trusted” merchants by default and you will have to click on “Show all” to see the rest.
The most affected services are TheFind, ShopWiki, and Froogle. In my tests they produced the largest number of results, however the merchants in the list that have the lowest price are often nothing else than scam shops. Read this extended PC World research for details on the tricks that these merchants employ to get you on the hook.
Prices and merchants change every day
I didn’t finish my test within a day and had to continue next morning. What I noticed right away is that some merchants have changed prices, some merchants were removed, and others were added. The picture overall has significantly changed. This brought me to an important conclusion. If you can’t find today what you want for the price you like, wait till tomorrow. Certain sites (e.g. Nextag) publish price trend graphs that will assist you when in doubt.
Sometimes websites go down
This is exactly what happened during my tests. The message below was up during a good part of the day yesterday at MSN shopping. Now tell me Microsoft software is reliable. ;-)
My search results
I used keyword “sony sr300” in my tests. Sony SR300 is Sony’s flagman consumer camcorder released earlier this year. Here are my results, excluding the websites that republish the content they obtain from other companies (see my previous post on this).
(*) indicates that the price doesn’t include shipping charges. This also may mean that the website doesn’t offer the functionality to show the shipping charges on products. I highlighted the best results using bold font.
| Web Site | Results | Best Result | |
|---|---|---|---|
| shopping.yahoo.com | 26 | $712 (*) | PrestigeCamera |
| froogle.google.com | 61 | $735 | FotoSprint |
| shopper.cnet.com | 17 | $749 | ButterflyPhoto |
| shopping.com | 12 | $777 | AbesOfMaine |
| nextag.com | 18 | $739 | EnterprisePhoto |
| pricegrabber.com | 20 | $749 | ButterflyPhoto |
| shopzilla.com | 26 | $766 | FotoConnection |
| smarter.com | 33 | $739 | EnterprisePhoto |
| pricerunner.com | 15 | $749 | ButterflyPhoto |
| pricewatch.com | 0 | doesn’t list any of Sony SR line | |
| become.com | 26 | $749 | PrestigeCamera |
| ebates.com | 0 | doesn’t list any of Sony SR line | |
| thefind.com | 30 | $731 (*) | WildDigital |
| sortprice.com | 5 | $732 (*) | Access2Digital |
| like.com | 0 | offers no/few technology products | |
| pricescan.com | 14 | $739 | EnterprisePhoto |
| jellyfish.com | 0 | only lists the previous model, SR 200 | |
| pronto.com | — | couldn’t get search to work | |
| activeshopper.com | 6 | $777 | AbesOfMaine |
| shopwiki.com | 88 | ||
| streetprices.com | 8 | $742 | BroadwayPhoto |
| mytriggers.com | 30 | $769 | eBay |
My overall impression, recommended websites
Looking at all the websites, I will single out a few that I liked the most and explain why. I excluded all sites that don’t calculate shipping charges. I think this is a critical piece of price comparison. Also, Shopping.com didn’t make my list. While I like the site a lot, it is hard to find a bargain taking into account how many other sites republish the content.
- NexTag — simple no frills interface, price history chart
- PriceGrabber — simple interface, mobile version of the engine
- ShopWiki — biggest selection of products, watch out for scam
- PriceRunner — transparency with results, international scope
roboshopper hmm…I use roboform from time to time…same company? thanks
I really enjoy reading your blog and I’m so glad I came upon it! You have provided me with more tips on bargain shopping than any other site I’ve been to.
Thank you!
Eve, it is my pleasure. And thanks for your great comments. They are what encourages me to keep writing!
Your article was quite helpful to me. I’ve been shopping for an SR-300 for quite some time and everytime I would find a cheap(er) price, it would turn out to not have a battery, software, etc, that would cost another $300. The article by PC World you referenced was also very helpful, since they researched a group that I keep seeing come up very frequently. I love shopping on the web, but I am concerned that these scam groups will put a damper on it, since it will tend to make people distrustful of what they are actually getting. So, I’m thankful you’re looking into this.
Thanks so much for the info.. I found a GREAT site for discount perfumes, scentiments. Anytime I ever go to the mall and see people buying outrageously priced perfume I tell than about it. Thanks again for your prices comparison information..