The tires on my car have all worn out and it is about time to get them replaced. Where should I go to buy a new set? I decided to do some research to find out what place offers the best deals on tires.
To get a good picture I picked up a few popular brands and went online to get a price quote from several different places. Below are two tables with the result of my research.
The first table is for merchants selling tires only online. If you buy through them, you will have to pay for shipping but most likely you will save on sales tax.
The second table is for merchants who have a network of shops/stores where you can pick up your tires and so save on shipping costs. All these stores will charge you tax though.
My town charges tax at 7.25% rate which comes to around $20-35 on a set of 4 tires. This is less than what most online stores charge for shipping, which gives local merchants a slight advantage provided they offer comparable tire prices.
In addition the first table has a column for tire parameters. These are relative ratings of different qualities of the tire: load index, speed rating, threadwear grade etc. All listed tires are T, H or V speed rated which is more than enough for a family car. You can read about what these ratings mean here and here.
Online stores
| TireRack | TireSavings | 1010Tires | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BFGoodrich Traction T/A | 94H | 440 AA A | $72 | $70 | |
| BFGoodrich Traction T/A | 94V | 440 AA A | $93 | ||
| Bridgestone Potenza RE92 | 92T | 160 A A | $62 | $79 | $113 |
| Continental ProContact | 94H | 400 AA A | $70 | $66 | |
| Dunlop SP Sport 4000 | 92H | 340 A A | $64 | ||
| Falken ZE 512 ZIEX | 94H | 420 A A | $50 | $60 | |
| Falken ZE 512 ZIEX | 94V | 420 A A | $65 | $75 | |
| Goodyear Eagle GT-HR | 92H | 440 A A | $65(*) | $132 | |
| Goodyear Integrity | 92T | 460 A B | $67 | ||
| Goodyear Eagle LS | 92T | 360 A B | $67(**) | $88 | |
| Michelin HydroEdge | 92T | 800 A B | $98 | $88 | |
| Michelin Energy MXV4+ | 94H | 400 A A | $114 | $105 | |
| Yokohama AVID H4S | 92H | 500 AA A | $69 | $69 | $132 |
| Appx. shipping to IL (set of 4) | $32 | $57 | $86 | ||
Local merchants
| SamsClub | Sears | Walmart | DiscountTire | NTB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BFGoodrich Traction T/A (H) | $76.82 | $88 | $83.94 | $87 | $90 |
| BFGoodrich Traction T/A (V) | $94.13 | $102.54 | |||
| Bridgestone Potenza RE92 | $81.66 | $92 | $99 | ||
| Continental ProContact | $86 | $89 | |||
| Dunlop SP Sport 4000 | $71 | $78 | $90 | ||
| Falken ZE 512 ZIEX (H) | $73 | $75 | |||
| Falken ZE 512 ZIEX (V) | $86 | ||||
| Goodyear Eagle GT-HR | $75.62 | $80.74 | $74.94 | $72(*) | |
| Goodyear Integrity | $70.64 | $71.44 | $77 | $80 | |
| Goodyear Eagle LS | $94.33 | $120.28 | $87(**) | ||
| Michelin HydroEdge | $107.86 | $125 | $119.16 | $111 | $112 |
| Michelin Energy MXV4+ | $109.74 | $123 | $133.58 | $115 | $114 |
| Yokohama AVID H4S | $84 | ||||
All prices are quoted for 205/65R15 tire size. (*) — price includes $5 manufacturer mail in rebate. (**) — price includes $10 manufacturer mail in rebate
Other considerations
I looked up tires at Costco as well and Costco seem to carry just two brands from my list with prices approximately the same as Walmart’s. They however often run promotions in summer time offering cash back on certain brands which makes their pricing somewhat more attractive.
Costco has very low installation fee. They only charge $10 per tire plus $1 environmental fee. Other shops can be much more expensive, for example when I bought a set of 4 tires at DiscountTire last year they charged me $51.80 for installation and $18 in other fees.
Installing tires at Costco and DiscountTire means you get free lifetime flat repairs and rotations. I am not sure about other shops (can anyone comment?). DiscountTire also offers free lifetime balancing. From my experience, once you install tires you usually don’t need to balance them unless you damage the rim.
Conclusion
Among online retailers TireRack seems to be taking the lead with low shipping charges and competitive prices. TireSavings however is not that far behind. These two merchants combined offer the best deals on tires across both categories, online and off-line.
Picking the winner just among local retailers is a bit harder. The lowest price is less of a factor since most of these merchants will do a price match. If you buy and install from one of these shops, pay attention to what they charge for installation since this will likely be the deal breaker. Additional benefits (like life time rotations) can be a plus as well.
Great comparison Yan.
Costco seems to be a good bet for just about anything these days. The warranty at Discount Tire sounds OK, but I would like to see the fine print. Pep-Boys always seemed to have a catch on their car battery warranties… :(
Great post! Thanks for the information; we’re in the pricing boat right now too.
I recently received a Costco coupon book with a coupon for $60 off a set of 4 Michelin or select BF Goodrich tires, good 4 June thru 1 July. Costco members should be sure to watch for these booklets; they can add to the savings. (In some cases, $60 looks like it’s almost enough to cover one of the tires for a car, though I doubt it will for our SUV that needs them right now. LOL)
I have studied the pros & cons of local .vs. online tire purchases. I did buy online once (TireRack.com) – I really like their website. However, since that one online tire purchase I haven’t been able to justify the “hassle factor” involved in receiving the tire shipment then finding a reasonable priced local installer and hauling the tires to them.
With careful online shopping and investing my time in getting the tires installed I can save at best maybe $10-$50. I have decided that ~$40-$50 is the hassle / savings threshold and I will usually opt to make my life easier rather than save
The best overall price/value is Sams Club. You get a very good quality tire, but the best part is the warranty and nationwide availability. (except for places like NYC.)
If there is a Farm and Fleet in your area, they have BFG Traction T/A tires on sale until June 17 PLUS they give you a free one when you buy 3. On our Civic, that came to just under $231 (all inclusive, including balancing, stems, mounting, taxes, disposal fees for 4 tires).
Sears automotive usually will beat anyones price by 10% on the same exact tire including tirerack so my suggestion shop on line buy at sears.
try UNSERTIRE.COM they have some pretty low prices and free shipping in the usa and they have a wide variety of name brands