Archive for the 'Deal Site Reviews' Category



Daily Deal Site - Deals2Buy Review

Having decided to review any heavily popular deal site, I used Yan’s recent update of popular deal sites to find the website I want to review. Wanting to review site among the top 10 in the list, a quick peruse of the list showed a weird number there, Deals2Buy which is in the 4th position has a Google rank of just 3, while every website in the top 10 has a Google rank of 5 or 6. To be more specific, except for deals2buy.com every other site in the top five has a Google rank of 6. Hunting for a reason, my best guess was that deals2buy.com was the only site without a forum while every other site in top 10 had a “forum”. It’s well known that Google ranks sites better for “original”/”new” content while penalizes for duplicate content. Given these reasons, I found it really impressive that deals2buy.com could be at the top 4th position, taking Amazon ranks at its face value. Forums for sure attract committed/dedicated users and can drive traffic really up. But with no forum nor any personalized feature (features requiring users to signup), driving traffic really requires something else. So here goes my review about deals2buy.com.

Top Deal Sites

Before beginning to review lets list some items we would like to see in a daily deal website:

  • Quickly be able to see the hottest deals for the day
  • Provide methods to view deals selectively
  • Every deal listed is expected to be best possible
  • All possible rebates, coupons etc need to be clearly mentioned along with exact steps to make sure the deal is secured
  • Methods to alert interested users about deals

Deals2Buy has a plain simple look to its home page (may be I should write Web 1.0 look) listing all the deals for the day paginated. Right above the list of deals there are options to sort the deals by clicking on links. However there is no mention whether the links are to sort or filter. I indeed expected it to be a filtering link, while it sorted. Sorting can be done based on whether tech deals appear on top or bottom, price, deals with no mail-in-rebates on top, category, merchant. Added to the set of links meant to sort is a link titled “text version”, which takes to a light weight version (only loads one liners for each deal and on clicking of an icon expands to load that particular deal from the server). The box which carries these links carries an image with the text “hot deals” on it. Clicking on it just resets the sorting you set (takes you to the home page), which was not the action I expected to happen. Could have just not made it a link!

Continue reading ‘Daily Deal Site - Deals2Buy Review’

Price Comparison Site - Pricegrabber Reviewed

Having decided to review online deal sites, picking the first site was a bit puzzling. There were numerous questions like should it be a new site, should it be a infamous site, should it be one of the leading sites, should it be a daily deal site or a price comparison site and so on. And while just browsing through several deal sites, I noticed that they were either a price comparison site or a daily deal site with little links called “Price Comparison” next to each deal. Most (not all) of the daily deal sites seem to partner with PriceGrabber and thus these “Price Comparison” links take you to a slightly different looking version of PriceGrabber.com with the header and footer edited to look like the site you came from (the daily deal site). To the best of my estimates, this trend of including a “Price Comparison” link next to each deal in a daily deal site started about a year ago and has slowly but steadily spread. This makes PriceGrabber a website visited by pretty much anyone deal hunting online and with their new found higher popularity (not that they were not popular earlier), I thought they would be a good choice for my first review and here it is for you.

People visit price comparison websites with the following expectations:

  1. Be able to choose a product based on various technical details and features of the product.
  2. Analyze the reliability of the product based on the product reviews.
  3. Find the seller with the cheapest price.
  4. Analyze the reliability of the seller.

Now let’s see how PriceGrabber performs in these fronts with some objective testing as well my subjective view points. Before that, let’s see a generic review of the website.

Continue reading ‘Price Comparison Site - Pricegrabber Reviewed’

Bargainist — hot deals for guys and girls

The Bargainist ChickThis post continues my weekly series of bargain site reviews. Last time I reviewed DealNews, a website with 10 years of experience in bargain hunting.

Dejarik Media, the blog network behind Uncrate.com and Outblush.com, two stylish blogs entertaining fancy male and female shoppers, made a big splash in November 2006 when they launched Bargainist, which is the bargain site of this week.

The team is doing very well with their two shopping blogs and it was a very logical step for them to extend their offering to a more frugal part of their readers community, to those who won’t blow $165 for a belt buckle.

A deals site or a deals blog?

Bargainist has a typical blog layout, each bargain is served as a separate blog post with several posts added daily. The website has a Stores section with promotions sorted by stores, and Archives where you can browse past deals by month, category, and store. Coupons and Freebies sections have, you guessed it, coupons and freebies. Tips section has,… nothing as of the moment. I figure the team is too busy sweeping deals and at the end of the day has no time left for any tips. Maybe they should borrow some from my blog? ;-)

Non-commissionable deals

Most of the deal links go to affiliate sites (nothing unusual) but the team does post a non-commissionable freebie once in a while, which is a good sign. A big problem with many deal sites is that they will ignore a good deal if they can’t earn a commission on it. There is no incentive for them to publish these deals, or rather the incentive is too far stretched to realize their importance.

The truth is that in the long run, the effort they put into posting non-commissionable deals will pay back to them many times and then more in a form of regular customers who will advocate the website to their friends and will help make it a success.

No deals on weekends

The site is not updated during weekends which is a pity since good shopping deals happen 24/7. As I am writing this on Sunday night, the last deal is posted 2 days ago, on Friday.

What puts Bargainist apart from many of the other deals sites is the broad selection of deals. They are not too geeky for women, and offer enough hi-tech gadgets to attract guys as well, a perfect combination.

I like the simple blog-style design of the website however it certainly lacks the bells and whistles that other deals sites offer. For one thing they could have at least enabled readers comments!

Summary

Overall a nice deals site (or rather blog) with a distinct design, featuring a well balanced combination of deals that appeal both men and women.

Pros: simple design makes it easy to browse the deals, wide deals variety, non-commissionable deals are not ignored
Cons: deals are not updated on weekends, some advanced features are lacking (can’t discuss deals, can’t compare prices on similar merchandise, etc)

Dealnews — bargain hunting built on trust

This post continues my weekly series of bargain site reviews. Last time I reviewed DealsPlus, a popular social bargain hunting site.

Dealnews is number 4 in my list of bargain sites however they might well be the number one if you took away the forums that bring most of the traffic to Slickdeals and Fatwallet, and PC hardware reviews that keep Anandtech in the third position.

It all started with catering to Apple Mac fans

Daniel de Grandpre and Richard Moss, two school buddies, started the business in 1997, and named it Deal-Mac.com (the logo below is courtesy of WaybackMachine). I can imagine what running an online business was like in 1997. I launched my first project in 1996 and competition was scarce, if any at all.

Deal-Mac

Presently the company employs 15 people and uses proxy software, load balancers, and dedicated image servers to feed the hungry bargain hunters who consume the deals at an average rate of 80 page requests per second during busy holiday shopping time.

One domain to rule them all

As the owners gradually realized Macintosh was not the only kind of computer, they launched Dealnews which was supposed to serve what didn’t seat well with Mac fans at Dealmac. Later more domains were added and as of today Dealnews serves as an umbrella for six more sites:

  • dealcam is a search engine for digital cameras and camcorders. Just one comment, where are the hard drive based camcorders? They have been around for a few years now…
  • dealram is a computer memory (RAM) search engine. I have always used the Memory Pricing Guide by SharkyExtreme before, but I will sure give dealram a try next time I upgrade memory on my PC
  • dealink is a printer ink search engine. It looks very nice however I wish laser printers were included. I switched to laser a while ago and I am glad I did. Ink related expenses can be a drag
  • her.dealnews has relatively few gadgets, mostly stuff that girls will fancy. A very smart marketing move by the team. Women spend more time shopping online as internet becomes more human friendly
  • dealcoupon is a directory of coupons and discounts. It doesn’t seem to be as complete as that of FatWallet. Coupons is clearly not Dealnews speciality.
  • dealmac has almost the same deals as dealnews but offers some emphasis on Apple related products.

These sections each used to have their own domain name but dealcam, dealram, dealink, and dealcoupons now branch off of Dealnews while her.dealnews is a sub-domain. This is clearly an attempt to optimize these sites for search results.

Dealmac is the only site that has not been incorporated into Dealnews. This is probably due to the enormous number of back-links it collected since 1998. In my opinion Dealmac adds little value as a separate website, many deals are the same as at Dealnews.

Dealnews editorial guarantee

Dealnews has gathered a huge following over the 10 years it has been in business. Some of my older friends have not even heard of other bargain sites. Most likely they don’t care since Dealnews does a great job of supplying a fresh set of hot shopping deals every day. Besides, trust is a very good foundation for a successful online service. This is taken from the Dealnews about page:

Every deal we list is the lowest price we could find for that product, sold by a reputable store.

Almost sounds like Dealnews will price match any of the deals they list. ;-) In life it comes to these three simple things (from the same page):

We never list a higher price from another store just because it is an advertiser.
We ban any store that we find has a history of poor customer service.
We list the best deals period, regardless of our relationship with the seller.

These are very good principles that I wish every bargain site promoted and incorporated. Many online shoppers take #1 and #3 for granted, while #2 is a good addition (making a trip to ResellerRatings unnecessary). You don’t want to disappoint your clients, do you?

Have you ever been Yahooed?

Here are some fun facts from the life of Dealnews. Many bloggers know what it means to be Dugg or Slashdotted. It happens when your blog gets to the front page of aforementioned news sites and usually results into a huge influx of new visitors and a stress to the web-server.

Brian Moon, a programmer and system administrator at Dealnews, runs a personal blog where he recently went over describing what it means to be front-paged by Yahoo!

Digg? Slashdot? They can bring traffic for sure. We have been on both several times. But wow, just getting in the third paragraph of an article that is one page deep from the Yahoo! front page can bring you to your knees if you are not ready.

During the 3 hour spike Dealnews was surviving 400 req/s for the pages and 1500 req/s for images. Wow!

Your opinion on DealNews needed

Update: feedback gathered, verdict announced. Please read the DealNews review to find the outcome of my research.

DealNews logoIt is time for my next bargain site of the week review and I decided to take a different route this time. I am going to write about DealNews this week, but before I do so I want to hear your opinion about the website and the people behind it. What do you know about it — the good, the bad, and the ugly.

I would really like to hear both sides of the story, from people using it for bargain hunting as well as from competitors or anyone active in affiliate marketing. The owners are welcome to comment as well — it is an open discussion.

One thing I heard and want to confirm is that DealNews can be very pushy with newsletters and follow up emails, and it can be hard to opt out. Is this really so?

Send me your thoughts by email or just leave them as comments to this post. I will incorporate them into my DealNews review next week.




Share your bargains

Hot Deals

Sponsors

Financial Web - The Independent Financial Portal

Learn how to take control of your financial future. Need a loan? We’ll help you find the best cash advance or low-interest personal loan. Rebuilding your credit? There’s a credit card waiting for you, along with mortgage calculators for every need.